I'm a pretty hard-and-fast, black-and-white, straight-and-narrow kind of a guy. I don't believe in excuse-making or gray areas. I believe in the teachings of the Church, just about all of them, and if I disagree with the teachings of the Church in some area I usually try to assume for my own sake that the Church is wiser than I am.
It's often the hardest teachings of the Church that I endorse most whole-heartedly, the kind that some folks don't necessarily want to talk about or know about. I believe that the teachings of the Church point the way concretely to love, and oftentimes those teachings can appear counterintuitive or even mean to us, but that just means we have to be "transformed by the renewal of our minds," to try to come as close as we can to understanding and believing these difficult teachings. I am a firm believer in these doctrines in their entirety and if anyone in the room voices a disagreement with the Church that teaches them under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and I say nothing, it's because I'm keeping my mouth shut.
All of the above describes my belief in my head and in my heart. But there's a third factor, and that's the one that is the most difficult for any Christian, at least, Christians like me, to corral into the stable of faith. And that's my will. No matter how strongly I believe in my head and in my heart what the Church teaches about how to do the right thing, time and time again I fail to do it. Sometimes I feel like on a good day all that happens is I fail to do the right thing. The bad days are when not only do I fail to do what's right, but I end up doing what's wrong. And like I said, I don't make excuses, at least not for myself.
People, especially priests, tell me all the time that I shouldn't beat up on myself and they're probably right, but it's frustrating. I've at times even felt like it's a form of schizophrenia. Think about it. You're up, you're down, you're good, you're bad, you're faithful, but then you're doubting. As your will goes, so goes your body, and so goes your mind: you're changing it all the time. It's like two different persons. The single greatest source of doubt for me in my spiritual life is my sinfulness. If all of this is true, if everything that Christ and His Church teach about love is true, if it's true that I'm supposed to live this way, then why can't I? Of course the answer is that I can, but I simply choose not to. But that just changes the question. If it is true that this is the best way to live, then why do I choose time and time again not to?
St Paul wrote about this situation in Romans 7, and we see it throughout the readings coming up this Palm Sunday. In the opening gospel the people are singing Jesus' praises. In the first reading from Isaiah the prophet is absolutely confident in God. "The Lord God is my help, therefore I am not disgraced; I have set my face like flint, knowing that I shall not be put to shame."
But then immediately in the Psalm we are faced with the well-known message, "My God, my God, why have you abandoned me?" We go from iron-clad trust in God to wondering where he's shimmied off to. Then we're presented with the image of Christ himself, the conclusive answer to that question, for he is "Immanuel," "God with us." The reading proclaims that "at the name of Jesus, every knee should bend." Is that what happens?
Our answer comes in the next reading, the Gospel. It is the Passion and Death of Jesus Christ as told by the Evangelist Mark. The people in the gospels read this Sunday go from "Hosanna in the highest!" to "Crucify him!" Sound familiar? The gospels are not merely a historical recounting of the events surrounding the death of Christ. God uses those events to tell the story of the struggle of fallen humanity, the struggle that takes place inside of everyone.
Is it possible to live a life that is really righteous? I have to believe in hope that the answer is yes. And the reason again lies in the gospel to be read this Sunday. One phrase I hear often but wholly disagree with is the phrase, "I can't help it; I'm human." The fact that we are human is not a sufficient explanation for our sinfulness, in fact it is our humanity that is the very reason we ought not to be sinful. For Jesus was human par excellence. All a human person is is a psychosomatic union created in the image and likeness of God possessing intellect and free will. That's all a human is. Sinfulness is in no way a constitutive element of humanity. Sinfulness did not enter the human picture until Genesis 3. All else already existed in Genesis 1. It is not that in Genesis 1 human beings were not human. It is that they were not fallen.
The problem today is that we are fallen. How do we get back up? The answer again comes from the gospel. It is through Jesus that we are raised out of our sinful nature. And it is not that we become superhuman. It is that we are raised from corruption to the pure humanity that God fashioned from "the beginning." For by "dying he destroyed our death, rising he restored our life." Jesus' death and resurrection makes it really possible for us to live as he lived, if we are baptized into his death and resurrection.
But then again I am confronted with my experience of life. With the fact that I have tried to grab hold of that grace for myself and have never been able to. For all the tricks I have ever tried, all the prayers I have ever prayed, all the penances I have ever made, I have never found that ultimate righteousness. The kind of righteousness that never exhausts itself. How can one really live this way?
It's a question I can't answer fully at this stage in life. But if there's anything I can say now, I think part of the answer lies in recognizing that grace is only given and received. It cannot be taken. So we as receivers of grace have to allow God to give the grace himself. Put another way, we have to surrender the struggle for righteousness to him. It's kind of like the "Happy Place." Before we can begin to do better we have to stop beating up on ourselves. And in order to stop beating up on ourselves, we have to allow Jesus to love us.
That's the key. We have to allow Jesus to love us. For any sin we commit is effectively a decision not to allow Jesus to love us. Therefore in order for actions to really bear fruit, in order for us to be able to perform them in a tireless way and to avoid sin in a tireless way as Jesus did, then all we do must spring from the desire to allow Jesus to love us. To surrender the struggle for righteousness to him. It is the key not only to sanctity, but at an even more basic level, to sanity.